Skip to main content
Comparison

ShieldMarc vs Red Sift OnDMARC

For UK MSPs and IT teams who want every price published, not just the entry tier.

ShieldMarc is a flat-priced, self-serve alternative to Red Sift OnDMARC for DMARC monitoring, with every tier published at £0, £50 and £100 per month (annual). OnDMARC has a single priced entry tier, with contact-sales tiers above it (checked 19 October 2026).

Red Sift is a UK-headquartered, strongly certified email authentication platform (ISO 27001, SOC 2 Type II, Cyber Essentials) and a genuinely credible choice. This comparison is not a jurisdiction fight, because both companies are UK-based.

Where ShieldMarc wins is pricing transparency, flat multi-domain plans, and breadth. Lookalike, SSL, DNS and uptime monitoring are included in one dashboard rather than sold as separate products.

We describe how Red Sift prices OnDMARC rather than quoting its prices, which change often. The pricing model below is from its pricing page, checked 19 October 2026.

Check current prices on Red Sift's OnDMARC pricing page before you decide. ShieldMarc's plans and prices, in pounds, are on our pricing page.

Every tier published vs one priced tier

Red Sift shows a price for one OnDMARC tier: Express, a “starting at” figure for a small estate with a month of data history. Essentials, Enterprise and Premier are all “Contact us” (checked 19 October 2026). ShieldMarc publishes every tier: £0, £50 and £100 per month (annual), plus expansion buckets at £40/mo. No quote cycle at any scale.

Flat multi-domain plans

Each OnDMARC contact-sales tier sets an allowance of active sender domains, upgradable to unlimited at a price agreed with sales (checked 19 October 2026). ShieldMarc Professional covers 25 domains for £50/mo annual and MSP covers 100 domain slots for £100/mo, with published expansion at £40/mo per bucket.

One dashboard, not three products

In the Red Sift Pulse Platform, lookalike detection (Brand Trust) and certificate monitoring (Certificates) are separate paid products, and there is no uptime monitoring product. ShieldMarc bundles lookalike, SSL, DNS and uptime monitoring into its paid tiers, in a single subscription.

How each prices (checked 19 October 2026)

FeatureRed Sift OnDMARCShieldMarc
Pricing modelA tiered SaaS model, each tier with its own volume-usage caps; payment in pounds, US dollars, euros or Australian dollarsTwo flat paid plans in pounds: Professional £50/mo and MSP £100/mo billed annually
Free tierNone. Every tier offers a free trial, no credit card requiredStarter: 1 domain, 10,000 messages/mo, 1 year retention, 20 free tools
Published entry tier

'Starting at' pricing scales with usage

Express: a “starting at” price, billed annually, for a small estate with a month of data historyProfessional: £50/mo annual, 25 domains, 1M messages/mo, 1-year retention
What the entry tier withholdsNo Unlimited Dynamic SPF (capped at 10 SPF lookups) and only a month of data history; real-world use pushes you to unpublished tiersFull paid feature set from £50/mo: SSL, DNS and uptime monitors, 1-year retention and Dynamic SPF; the SPF flattener is free on every plan
Published pricing above the entry tierNone. Essentials, Enterprise and Premier are all contact-salesEvery tier published: £50 and £100/mo (annual), expansion buckets £40/mo
Domain allowancesCapped on Express; each contact-sales tier sets an allowance of active sender domains, upgradable to unlimited at a price agreed with sales25 on Professional, 100 slots on MSP, +50 slots per £40/mo bucket
Monthly message volumeCapped on Express; unlimited on the contact-sales tiers1M on Professional, 5M on MSP; no hard cap, 3-month grace
Platform usersUnlimited on every tier, including Express1 on Starter, 5 on Professional, unlimited on MSP
Data historyA month on Express; a year on the contact-sales tiers1 year on every plan, including the free Starter tier
Billing optionsMonthly or annual; only Express shows a priceMonthly or annual on every paid tier (Professional £70/£50, MSP £130/£100)
Can you estimate your cost upfront?Only on Express. Beyond it, a sales cycleYes, for every standard case. Enterprise is only for SLA, hosting or compliance specifics

Features and depth

FeatureRed Sift OnDMARCShieldMarc
Analysis engine

Threat model on every plan; AI on paid plans and the free trial, on demand only. We combine both.

Red Sift Radar (LLM assistant): sold as Pro seats, a few bundled with each of the top tiers (Enterprise and Premier); no seats bundled on Express or EssentialsProprietary threat model on all plans, plus AI on paid tiers
SPF lookup-limit handlingDynamic SPF (flagship): unlimited lookups without macros, but contact-sales tiers only; Express is capped at 10 lookupsDynamic SPF on Professional and MSP, at published prices: one include, kept current and inside the 10-lookup limit; free SPF flattener on every plan
Hosted / managed DNS recordsDynamic Services manage DMARC, SPF, DKIM, MTA-STS, TLS-RPT and BIMI in-platformHosts SPF (Dynamic SPF, Professional and MSP); DMARC, DKIM, MTA-STS and TLS-RPT are monitored with guided fixes, not hosted; no BIMI
BIMI and VMCIntegrated VMC provisioning; one VMC bundled on Enterprise and PremierNot offered
Lookalike domain scanningNot in OnDMARC; sold separately as Red Sift Brand TrustMonitoring included on Professional, MSP and the 30-day free trial; a free one-off scanner for anyone
SSL certificate monitoringSeparate product (Red Sift Certificates)Included on every plan: one monitor on Starter, unlimited on Professional and MSP
Uptime monitoringNo uptime monitoring product on the Pulse PlatformIncluded on paid tiers
DNS hygiene monitoring

Different tools: DNS Guardian targets takeover attacks; ours covers record health

DNS Guardian (anti-takeover monitoring): reserved for the top contact-sales tiers, custom pricingDNS health monitoring (DNSSEC, MTA-STS, TLS-RPT, CAA) on paid tiers from £50/mo
Subdomain policy (sp=) detectionNot detailed on their public plan pagessp= scored independently, weaker-than-p flagged as a distinct control failure
MSP programmeDedicated MSP programme: multi-tenancy, RBAC, SAML/SSO/SCIM, partner portal, Pax8 distributionMSP plan at a published £100/mo: 100 domain slots, TLD grouping, unlimited seats
Brand TLD grouping (MSP)Not advertisedTLD variants count as one slot
Path to enforcementVendor cites a typical 6-8 week path to p=rejectPrioritised tasks per domain; pace depends on your senders

Data, hosting and privacy

FeatureRed Sift OnDMARCShieldMarc
Company baseUK-headquartered (Redsift Limited, London), ICO-registered, with a US arm in Austin, TexasUK owned and run
Data residencyUK, EU and USA regional residency optionsEU hosted by default, UK hosting on request on an enterprise plan
InfrastructureIBM Cloud and/or Microsoft Azure core, with Google Cloud for Dynamic ServicesRuns its own database, authentication and monitoring stack; savings passed into flat pricing
Third-party certificationsISO 27001 (A-LIGN), SOC 2 Type II, Cyber EssentialsCyber Essentials certification in progress; SOC 2 or ISO 27001 on the roadmap; our controls are documented on our Trust page
PII storedStandard SaaS profile; ICO-registered data controller with data encrypted at restMinimal by design: account emails, audit log, rare RUF headers

Before you compare dashboards: any DMARC tool can only show the aggregate reports your domain asks receivers to send. On 16 October 2026, 26 of the 192 UK managed service providers (14%) in ShieldMarc's Q3 2026 audit received none, most because they published no reporting address (rua=). The free DMARC checker shows whether yours has one.

Conclusion

Where ShieldMarc has an edge

  • Published pricing on every tier, including expansion buckets at £40/mo. Red Sift publishes only a 'starting at' price for Express; Essentials, Enterprise and Premier all require a sales cycle.
  • Flat multi-domain plans: 25 domains for £50/mo annual or 100 domain slots for £100/mo, versus a small entry tier and active-domain allowances on unpublished tiers.
  • A genuinely free Starter tier with 1 year of data retention. OnDMARC has no free tier, and its entry tier keeps only a month of history.
  • Lookalike scanning, SSL, DNS and uptime monitoring in one subscription. On the Red Sift Pulse Platform, lookalike detection (Brand Trust) and certificate monitoring (Certificates) are separate paid products, and uptime monitoring is not offered.
  • Paid-plan AI analysis combines our proprietary threat model with an AI model from £50/mo, on demand only. Radar seats are bundled only with the top contact-sales tiers (Enterprise and Premier).
  • Monthly or annual billing at published prices on every paid tier; OnDMARC publishes both only for Express.
  • Minimal personal data by design, suitable for DPIA-heavy public sector buyers.

Where Red Sift OnDMARC stacks up

  • Certifications today: ISO 27001 (audited by A-LIGN), SOC 2 Type II and Cyber Essentials. If your procurement requires these as hard gates, that may be decisive. ShieldMarc holds neither ISO 27001 nor SOC 2 Type II yet, and its Cyber Essentials certification is in progress.
  • Dynamic SPF is mature and OnDMARC's flagship: unlimited SPF lookups without macros on its contact-sales tiers. ShieldMarc's Dynamic SPF is new and sits on published-price plans (Professional and MSP).
  • Full hosted record management: Dynamic Services manage DMARC, SPF, DKIM, MTA-STS, TLS-RPT and BIMI in-platform, including integrated VMC provisioning for BIMI. ShieldMarc hosts SPF (Dynamic SPF) but not DMARC, DKIM, MTA-STS, TLS-RPT or BIMI records.
  • Unlimited platform users on every tier, and unlimited email volume on the contact-sales tiers.
  • UK-headquartered and ICO-registered, with UK, EU and USA data residency options, so jurisdictionally on par with ShieldMarc for a UK buyer.
  • An established MSP programme with multi-tenancy, RBAC, SAML/SSO/SCIM and Pax8 distribution, a more mature partner infrastructure than ShieldMarc's early-days MSP plan.
  • A published entry point for small estates: Express shows a starting price, billed monthly or annually, with a free trial and no card needed (checked 19 October 2026).
For full detail on our security posture, tenant isolation, audit logging and incident response see our Trust page. What personal data we hold (and do not hold) is set out in our Privacy Policy. For vendor assessments, DPIAs or procurement questionnaires, contact sales with the framework and we will respond with the relevant evidence. Red Sift OnDMARC is one of the strongest products in this category, and both platforms implement the same DMARC standard, published as RFC 7489, obsoleted in May 2026 by DMARCbis (RFC 9989), so the decision comes down to pricing transparency, how the price grows with your domain count and how much of your monitoring you want in one place. For the wider market view, see our 2026 guide to the best DMARC monitoring tools for UK buyers, which compares seven platforms on hosting region and how each one prices.

Frequently asked questions

What is an alternative to Red Sift OnDMARC for DMARC monitoring?

ShieldMarc is a flat-priced, self-serve alternative to Red Sift OnDMARC. It parses the same DMARC aggregate reports. It publishes every tier (£0, £50 or £100 per month on annual billing, with expansion buckets at £40 per month), where OnDMARC has a single priced entry tier with contact-sales tiers above it.

ShieldMarc also bundles lookalike scanning, SSL, DNS and uptime monitoring into one dashboard. Red Sift sells lookalike detection (Brand Trust) and certificate monitoring (Certificates) as separate products. Other alternatives include dmarcian, EasyDMARC and Valimail. Red Sift is also UK-headquartered, so the difference is pricing model and breadth, not jurisdiction.

How does ShieldMarc's pricing compare with Red Sift OnDMARC's?

It depends on your domain count. Red Sift shows a price only for OnDMARC Express, its tier for small estates. Express excludes Unlimited Dynamic SPF, caps SPF at 10 lookups and keeps a month of history. Essentials, Enterprise and Premier are priced through sales (all checked 19 October 2026).

ShieldMarc publishes every tier: Professional covers 25 domains for £50 per month and MSP covers 100 domain slots for £100 per month, billed annually. For a small estate, check Red Sift's pricing page for Express. Beyond it, ShieldMarc's cost is known before you talk to anyone, where OnDMARC's needs a quote.

Which is better for UK MSPs: Red Sift OnDMARC or ShieldMarc?

Both are UK-headquartered and both sell to MSPs. Red Sift sells through a partner programme, and ShieldMarc through a published MSP plan with no reseller or partner programme. It comes down to pricing model and scope.

Red Sift has a mature partner infrastructure (multi-tenancy, RBAC, SAML/SSO/SCIM, Pax8 distribution). It also has hosted record management including Dynamic SPF and BIMI with VMC provisioning. However, its MSP-scale tiers are contact-sales, each with an allowance of active sender domains.

ShieldMarc's MSP plan is a published £100 per month for 100 domain slots with TLD grouping, unlimited seats and expansion buckets at £40 per month. It includes lookalike, SSL, DNS and uptime monitoring that Red Sift sells as separate products.

If you need ISO 27001 or SOC 2 Type II today, Red Sift holds both. ShieldMarc's Cyber Essentials certification is in progress, with SOC 2 or ISO 27001 on its roadmap after it.

Try ShieldMarc free for 30 days

30-day free trial with 10 domains, no credit card, cancel anytime. See the difference on your own domains.

We use optional analytics cookies (Google Analytics) to understand how visitors use the site. Essential cookies are always on. Privacy policy