Skip to main content
Comparison

ShieldMarc vs DMARCLY

A straight comparison for UK MSPs weighing a US tool with published monthly tiers against a UK-owned platform.

ShieldMarc is a UK-owned, EU-hosted alternative to DMARCLY for DMARC monitoring. It has flat annual pricing at £0, £50 and £100 per month, instead of DMARCLY's four tiers, each with its own domain cap. DMARCLY is an independent US vendor (Seattle, WA) that publishes every price including its overage rates (rare in this market). Its top tier covers a large estate, so for a very small or a very large fixed estate it deserves a fair look.

Where ShieldMarc differs is one flat plan for a mid-size estate (25 domains for £50/mo annual) and a full year of data retention on every plan. ShieldMarc also has whole-domain monitoring beyond email authentication, a proprietary threat model plus AI on paid tiers, and a UK-owned / EU-hosted default.

We describe how DMARCLY prices rather than quoting its prices, which change often. The pricing model below is from DMARCLY's pricing page, checked 19 October 2026, where it publishes US dollar prices with monthly billing only.

Check current prices on DMARCLY's pricing page before you decide. ShieldMarc's plans and prices, in pounds, are on our pricing page.

Flat plans, not domain tiers

DMARCLY publishes four monthly tiers in US dollars, each capping domains, DMARC-compliant messages, users and history. Past a cap it charges per extra domain, or moves you to the next plan for a month your volume runs over (its pricing page, checked 19 October 2026). ShieldMarc Professional covers 25 domains for £50/mo annual and MSP covers 100 domain slots for £100/mo, with expansion buckets at £40/mo.

A year of data on every plan

DMARCLY's report history rises with the tier, from a couple of months on its entry tier to a year at most, even on Enterprise (checked 19 October 2026). ShieldMarc keeps 1 year of DMARC reports and changelogs on every plan, including the free Starter tier; uptime check results are kept for 90 days. Trend analysis and audit evidence need history.

Whole-domain scope plus threat model + AI

DMARCLY is deliberately email-authentication-only: no SSL, DNS health, uptime, domain expiry or lookalike monitoring, and no AI features advertised beyond automatic categorisation of unidentified senders. Paid ShieldMarc plans bundle all of those. Every plan runs each DMARC report row through our proprietary threat model. On paid plans and the free trial an AI model reasons on top, on demand only.

How each prices (checked 19 October 2026)

FeatureDMARCLYShieldMarc
Published pricesYes, in US dollars, for all four tiers, overage rates includedYes, in pounds: Professional £50/mo and MSP £100/mo billed annually
What the price depends onThe tier: each caps domains, DMARC-compliant messages a month, users, data history and Safe SPF domainsThe plan alone: 25 domains and 1,000,000 messages/mo on Professional, 100 domain slots and 5,000,000 messages/mo on MSP
Free tierNone: 14-day free trial on every tier, plus free SPF, DKIM, DMARC, BIMI and MTA-STS checkersStarter: 1 domain, 10,000 messages/mo, 20 free tools, 1 year retention, permanently free
Annual billing optionNot published: monthly pricing onlyYes: Professional £50/mo annual (£70 monthly), MSP £100/mo annual (£130 monthly)
How you buySelf-serve sign-up on every tierSelf-serve on every published plan
Free trial14 days on all plans30 days with 10 domains, no card required
Data retentionRises with the tier, from a couple of months on Professional to a year at most on Enterprise1 year on every plan, including free
Users includedCapped on Professional, Growth and Business; unlimited only on Enterprise5 on Professional, unlimited on MSP at £100/mo
Overage and expansion pricing

DMARCLY deserves credit for publishing its overage rates at all

Published: a charge per extra domain, per extra Safe SPF domain and per extra million messages above the top tier's allowance; a month over a plan's volume is billed at the next plan up+50 domain slots for £40/mo (published); no hard message cap, 3-month grace, your invoice never changes without a conversation first
What forces an upgradeEach tier's domain, message, user and Safe SPF caps; API and SAML SSO only on the Enterprise tierProfessional stops at 25 domains and 5 team members, so growing past either means MSP (100 domain slots, unlimited members); beyond that, published £40/mo expansion buckets

Features and depth

FeatureDMARCLYShieldMarc
Analysis engine

Threat model on every plan; AI on paid plans and the free trial, on demand only. We combine both.

No AI features advertised; automatic categorisation of unidentified sendersProprietary threat model + AI
Forensic (RUF) reports

A genuine DMARCLY plus: some competitors gate these behind higher tiers

Included on every plan, including the entry tierFull RUA and RUF on all plans, including forensic samples
SPF flattening

Both automate it; ShieldMarc charges no per-domain fee

Safe SPF automated flattening, live today, on a few domains from the Growth tier up, with a charge per domain beyond each tier's quota; not available on ProfessionalDynamic SPF keeps one include current for your domains on Professional and MSP, with no per-domain fee; the SPF flattener stays free on every plan, including Starter
Subdomain policy (sp=) detectionSubdomain detection on all planssp= scored independently, weaker-than-p flagged as a distinct control failure
Lookalike domain scanningNot offeredMonitoring included on Professional, MSP and the 30-day free trial; a free one-off scanner for anyone
SSL, DNS health, DNSSEC, CAA, domain expiry and uptime monitoringNot offered: deliberately email-authentication-only (DNS timeline of its monitored records only)All included on paid tiers
MTA-STS and TLS-RPTRecord generation and checking tools plus TLS report ingestion; MTA-STS policy hosting is customer-managed per its own guidesMTA-STS and TLS-RPT monitoring with TLS report ingestion on paid tiers; policy hosting is customer-managed too
BIMIRecord generation and checking tools on all plans (no hosted BIMI or VMC handling)Not a current focus; we do not ship hosted BIMI
Blacklist and IP reputation monitoringIP reputation monitoring on all plans; blacklist monitoring (Spamhaus ZEN, SpamCop, Barracuda, PSBL) from the Business tierIP reputation and ASN signals feed our threat model on every report row; no dedicated blacklist monitor
MSP toolingMSP dashboard to switch between client accounts; no white-label option or reseller/partner programme publishedMSP plan: every client's domains in one account, grouped by client, with a branded PDF report per client that can drop the "Powered by ShieldMarc" line (scheduled emails still come from ShieldMarc's mailbox); no separate client accounts, but you can invite a client's staff and limit them to that client's group; 100 domain slots, unlimited team members, brand TLD grouping (alternate TLDs count as one slot), published expansion buckets
Free tools and educationFree SPF, DKIM, DMARC, BIMI and MTA-STS checkers and an extensive setup-guide knowledge base20 free tools, 4 with plain-English AI explanations

Data, hosting and privacy

FeatureDMARCLYShieldMarc
Company baseUS-based (Seattle, WA), independent vendorUK owned and run
Default hostingUS (Fremont, CA) for dmarcly.com accounts; Frankfurt, Germany for eu.dmarcly.com accounts, per its privacy policy; cloud provider not namedEU hosted by default, UK hosted on request on an enterprise plan; we run our own stack
Subject to US CLOUD ActDMARCLY is based in Seattle, per its contact page, so US authorities can require it to disclose data it holds or controls, wherever the data is stored (US CLOUD Act, 18 U.S.C. § 2713; checked 19 October 2026). Its data processing agreement names NetFlare, Inc. as the processor without saying where it is incorporated, and its privacy policy puts eu.dmarcly.com accounts on DMARCLY servers in Frankfurt.UK company on EU servers, but reports arrive via Microsoft 365, raw report emails are archived in Cloudflare R2, and AI features call US providers
PII storedStandard SaaS profileMinimal by design: account emails, audit log, rare RUF headers
Third-party certificationsNo SOC 2 or ISO 27001 mentioned on its homepage, pricing, terms or privacy pages (checked 19 October 2026); GDPR compliance is self-declared with a downloadable DPA; 2FA on all plansCyber Essentials certification in progress; SOC 2 or ISO 27001 on the roadmap; our controls are documented on our Trust page
Public trust page and legal transparencyNo trust or status page linked from its homepage; its terms of service (updated 2 September 2020) and privacy policy call the operator DMARCLY, and the data processing agreement its privacy policy links to names NetFlare, Inc., with no address or registration number (checked 19 October 2026)Trust page documenting security posture, tenant isolation, audit logging and incident response
SupportEmail support on Professional, live chat from Growth; no phone support publishedSupport tickets on all plans; dedicated account manager on Enterprise

Before you compare dashboards: any DMARC tool can only show the aggregate reports your domain asks receivers to send. On 16 October 2026, 26 of the 192 UK managed service providers (14%) in ShieldMarc's Q3 2026 audit received none, most because they published no reporting address (rua=). The free DMARC checker shows whether yours has one.

Conclusion

Where ShieldMarc has an edge

  • Flat, predictable pricing for real-world estates: 25 domains for £50/mo annual, or 100 domain slots for £100/mo, with no domain tiers to step through. Past each DMARCLY tier's domain cap, you pay per extra domain or move up a tier.
  • Annual billing discount and a permanent free tier. DMARCLY publishes monthly-only pricing and offers a 14-day trial instead of a free plan.
  • A full year of data retention on every plan, including free. DMARCLY keeps a couple of months on its entry tier and a year at most, even on Enterprise.
  • Paid-plan AI analysis combines our proprietary threat model with an AI model, on demand only. DMARCLY advertises no AI features.
  • Full stack in one dashboard on paid tiers: DMARC, SPF, DKIM, SSL, DNS, DNSSEC, MTA-STS, TLS-RPT, CAA, domain expiry, uptime and lookalike monitoring. DMARCLY covers email authentication only, with no lookalike or typosquat detection.
  • Dynamic SPF on Professional and MSP has no per-domain fee, and a free SPF flattener comes on every plan. DMARCLY's Safe SPF covers a few domains per tier and charges per domain beyond them.
  • UK owned, EU hosted by default, UK hosted on request on an enterprise plan. Unlimited team members on MSP, against DMARCLY's seat caps below Enterprise.

Where DMARCLY stacks up

  • Fully transparent pricing at every tier, including published overage rates, with no 'contact sales' gatekeeping anywhere. That is rare in this market and deserves genuine credit.
  • A top tier built for large estates. It covers many times the domains of the tiers below it, with unlimited users and a published rate for each domain beyond. For a very large estate that needs DMARC reporting only, price it against ShieldMarc MSP and its expansion buckets for your domain count.
  • Forensic (failure) reports on every plan, including the entry tier, where some competitors gate them behind higher tiers.
  • Safe SPF automated flattening has been live for longer (from the Growth tier, on a few domains per tier); ShieldMarc's Dynamic SPF is new.
  • An EU data residency option via its Frankfurt instance (eu.dmarcly.com), unusual for a vendor of this size, though the operator remains a US company.
  • Strong free checkers (SPF, DKIM, DMARC, BIMI, MTA-STS) and an extensive setup-guide knowledge base.
  • An MSP dashboard for switching between separate client accounts; ShieldMarc keeps every client's domains in one account, grouped by client.
For full detail on our security posture, tenant isolation, audit logging and incident response see our Trust page. What personal data we hold (and do not hold) is set out in our Privacy Policy. For vendor assessments, DPIAs or procurement questionnaires, contact sales with the framework and we will respond with the relevant evidence. DMARCLY publishes every price including its overage rates; we respect that, and publish ours in full too. Both platforms implement the same DMARC standard, published as RFC 7489, obsoleted in May 2026 by DMARCbis (RFC 9989), so the decision comes down to pricing shape, data retention, monitoring scope and hosting rather than the protocol itself. Prices change, so check the current figures on the DMARCLY pricing page linked above before you commit.

Frequently asked questions

What is an alternative to DMARCLY for DMARC monitoring?

ShieldMarc is a UK-owned, EU-hosted alternative to DMARCLY. It parses the same DMARC aggregate and forensic reports. It keeps a full year of data on every plan (DMARCLY keeps a couple of months on its entry tier and a year at most on its top tier). On paid tiers it bundles SSL, DNS, DNSSEC, MTA-STS, TLS-RPT, CAA, uptime, domain expiry and lookalike monitoring alongside DMARC, with a proprietary threat model plus AI analysis on demand.

Pricing is flat: free on Starter for 1 domain, £50 per month annual for 25 domains on Professional, and £100 per month annual for 100 domain slots on MSP.

Other alternatives include dmarcian, EasyDMARC, Valimail and PowerDMARC. ShieldMarc differs by being UK owned with EU hosting by default and UK hosting available on request on an enterprise plan.

How does ShieldMarc's pricing compare with DMARCLY's?

It depends on your domain count, and both price lists are public, so compare them for your own estate. DMARCLY publishes four monthly tiers in US dollars, each capping domains, messages, users and history (checked 19 October 2026). It publishes overage charges and has no annual option (checked 19 October 2026). Its pricing page has today's figures.

ShieldMarc publishes two flat plans in pounds, billed annually. Professional covers 25 domains and 1 million messages for £50 per month. MSP covers 100 domain slots for £100 per month. Expansion buckets are £40 per month.

ShieldMarc also includes a permanent free tier, a year of retention on every plan, and SSL, DNS, uptime and lookalike monitoring that DMARCLY does not offer on any plan.

Which is better for UK MSPs: DMARCLY or ShieldMarc?

DMARCLY has a genuine MSP dashboard for switching between client accounts, but its tiers work against a growing MSP. Past each tier's domain cap you pay per extra domain or move up a tier, and seats are capped below Enterprise (its pricing page, checked 19 October 2026). Report history is a few months on the tiers most MSPs would start on (its pricing page, checked 19 October 2026). No white-label option or reseller/partner programme is published.

ShieldMarc has no separate client accounts to switch between. Its MSP plan keeps every client's domains in one account, grouped by client, with a branded report per client. You can invite a client's own staff with access to that client's group only. The MSP plan gives 100 domain slots for £100 per month annual and unlimited team members. Brand TLD grouping means alternate TLDs of the same client count as one slot. The MSP plan also covers SSL, DNS, uptime and lookalike monitoring across every client domain. Expansion buckets are published at £40 per month.

Being UK owned and EU hosted also simplifies DPIAs and client due diligence for UK books of business. DMARCLY remains a reasonable pick for a fixed estate of very few, or a great many, domains.

Try ShieldMarc free for 30 days

30-day free trial with 10 domains, no credit card, cancel anytime. See the difference on your own domains.

We use optional analytics cookies (Google Analytics) to understand how visitors use the site. Essential cookies are always on. Privacy policy